NEWSReport No. CS 97-26 CABLE SERVICES ACTION October 14, 1997 CABLE SERVICES BUREAU PREEMPTS RESTRICTIONS ON THE USE OF OVER- THE-AIR-RECEPTION DEVICES IMPOSED BY THREE HOMEOWNER ASSOCIATIONS The Cable Services Bureau has preempted restrictions imposed by three homeowner associations on the installation and use of satellite dishes, television antennas and wireless cable antennas. In separate orders deciding petitions for declaratory ruling filed by homeowners from San Antonio, Texas, Potomac, Maryland and McCormick, South Carolina, the Bureau found that the restrictions did not comply with the Commission's rule ("Rule") regarding over-the-air reception devices, which implements Section 207 of the 1996 Telecommunications Act. The Rule prohibits governmental and private restrictions that impair the ability of antenna users to install, maintain, or use satellite dishes and wireless cable antennas that are one meter or smaller in diameter and television broadcast antennas unless justified by safety or historic preservation considerations. These are the first orders addressing restrictions imposed by homeowner associations. Previously, the Bureau preempted a Meade, Kansas local ordinance which impermissibly restricted installation and use of satellite dishes and other antennas covered by the Rule. (In re Star Lambert et al., DA-97-1554, released July 22, 1997.) In the first of the three orders released today, C.S. Wireless (d/b/a/ OmniVision of San Antonio) petitioned the Commission for a ruling on restrictions imposed by Northampton Property Owners Association. OmniVision is a multichannel multipoint distribution services (MMDS) provider of wireless cable service in the San Antonio, Texas area. Wireless cable antennas operate on line-of-sight contact with the transmitter or repeater. The OmniVision order (DA 97-2187) holds that Northampton's outright prohibition of externally installed wireless cable antennas is not justified by either safety or historic preservation and is prohibited by the Rule. In the second order, Jay Lubliner and Deborah Galvin, homeowners in Potomac, Maryland, petitioned the Commission to preempt a restriction imposed by Potomac Ridge Homeowners Association that prohibits externally mounted television broadcast antennas. Mr. Lubliner and Ms. Galvin alleged they could not receive acceptable quality reception if their antenna was installed inside their attic, as required by the Association. In this order (DA 97-2188), the Bureau finds that the Potomac Ridge restriction against externally mounted television antennas is prohibited and unenforceable because the Association did not meet its burden to show that its restriction does not impair reception. -more- In the third order, Michael MacDonald, a homeowner in McCormick, South Carolina, petitioned the Commission for a ruling on restrictions imposed by the Savannah Lakes Property Owners Association. The MacDonald order rejects Savannah Lakes' assertion that it is exempt from the Rule because it is near a Paleo-Indian archeological site. The order (DA 97-2189) preempts Savannah Lakes' permit and prior approval requirements because they impose unreasonable delay on antenna installation in violation of the Rule. The order also finds that Savannah Lakes' requirement that antenna users hire an installer solely to certify that installation in the Association's preferred location would interfere with reception imposed unreasonable expense. Finally, the order preempts Savannah Lakes' placement preferences, screening and camouflaging requirements, and its threat to deny community privileges on the basis that they conflict with the Rule's prohibition of restrictions that impose unreasonable cost or unreasonable delay or prevent antenna installation, maintenance, or use unless necessary for safety or historic preservation considerations. Action by the Chief, Cable Services Bureau, October 10, 1997, by Orders (DA 97- 2187, DA 97-2188, DA 97-2189). --FCC-- News Media Contact: Morgan Broman at (202) 418-2358 Cable Services Bureau Contacts: Nancy Markowitz, Eloise Gore at (202) 418-7200