******************************************************** NOTICE ******************************************************** This document was converted from WordPerfect or Word to ASCII Text format. Content from the original version of the document such as headers, footers, footnotes, endnotes, graphics, and page numbers will not show up in this text version. All text attributes such as bold, italic, underlining, etc. from the original document will not show up in this text version. Features of the original document layout such as columns, tables, line and letter spacing, pagination, and margins will not be preserved in the text version. If you need the complete document, download the WordPerfect version or Adobe Acrobat version, if available. ***************************************************************** Before the Federal Communications Commission Washington, D.C. 20554 In the Matter of ) ) ICO-Teledesic Global Limited ) ) Application for Transfer of Control of ) File No. SAT-T/C-20000531-00097 Space Station License of Teledesic LLC ) Call Sign S2136 to ICO-Teledesic Global Limited ) ) ICO Services Limited ) File No. SAT-PDR-20000612-00106 Petition for Declaratory Ruling ) ) Amendment of Letter of Intent of ) File Nos. SAT-AMD-20000612-00107 ICO Services Limited to Access the ) SAT-LOI-19970926-0163 2 GHz MSS Frequency Bands ) 188-SAT-LOI-97 MEMORANDUM OPINION, ORDER AND AUTHORIZATION Adopted: January 8, 2001 Released: January 9, 2001 By the Chief, International Bureau: I. INTRODUCTION 1. In this Order, we grant ICO-Teledesic Global Limited ("ITGL") authority to transfer control of a license held by Teledesic LLC to construct, launch, and operate a non- geostationary orbit ("NGSO") Fixed Satellite Service ("FSS") system, from Teledesic Corporation ("Teledesic") to ITGL. We also address a related Petition for Declaratory Ruling filed by ICO Services Limited ("ICO") regarding the same transaction. Specifically, we grant ICO an exemption from the space station "cut-off" rule, which will allow ICO to continue prosecuting its pending letter of intent ("LOI") to access the 2 GHz Mobile Satellite Service ("2 GHz MSS") frequency bands. These actions will permit completion of the planned merger of Teledesic and ICO within a single organizational structure, ITGL, and will serve the public interest by facilitating rapid deployment and competition in the provision of advanced broadband services using ITGL's satellite authorizations. II. BACKGROUND 2. Teledesic LLC currently holds a license to implement an NGSO FSS system in the Ka-band frequencies. Teledesic LLC is controlled by Teledesic, a Delaware corporation, which is the Manager of Teledesic LLC and owns approximately 66.1% of its interests. Teledesic shares are held by a number of investors and no one shareholder has sufficient voting power to control the company single-handedly. However, Craig O. McCaw is Chairman of the Board and Co-Chief Executive Officer of Teledesic, manages Teledesic's business and affairs, and has significant Teledesic voting interests. Specifically, Mr. McCaw's investment company, Eagle River Investments LLC ("Eagle River"), owns 13.3% of Teledesic, and has 49.0% voting control by ownership or proxy. 3. ICO, a corporation organized under the laws of the United Kingdom, filed an LOI proposing to operate a 2 GHz MSS system in the United States. As a result of a reorganization in bankruptcy, ICO is 100% owned and controlled by New ICO Global Communications (Holdings), Inc. ("New ICO"), a Delaware corporation. New ICO's controlling shareholder is ITGL, a Delaware corporation. ITGL is controlled by Mr. McCaw through his investment company, Eagle River. 4. Teledesic, ICO, and ITGL now seek to effect a corporate reorganization designed to bring the satellite assets in which Mr. McCaw holds substantial interest within a single organizational structure, ITGL. On May 31, 2000, ITGL applied for authority to transfer control of the license held by Teledesic LLC from Teledesic to ITGL. On June 12, 2000, ICO filed an amendment to its LOI, disclosing the reorganization of the company pursuant to the bankruptcy proceedings, as well as the pending merger of Teledesic into ITGL. ICO also filed a Petition for Declaratory Ruling seeking to remove any uncertainty as to whether ICO's LOI should remain in the 2 GHz MSS processing round, given the significant ownership changes described in its amendment. 5. The proposed transaction would result in the following ownership structure: Teledesic LLC would remain controlled by Teledesic; ICO would remain a wholly-owned subsidiary of New ICO; and ITGL would be the parent of both Teledesic and New ICO. Eagle River (controlled by Mr. McCaw) would own stock representing 27.0% of the equity and 62.3% of the voting rights in ITGL; William H. Gates III would own stock representing 10.1% of the equity and 14.2% of the voting rights in ITGL; and the remaining 62.9% equity ownership and 23.5% voting rights would be held by current Teledesic LLC and New ICO shareholders, none of whom individually would hold a 10% or greater equity or voting interest. 6. The International Bureau placed these filings on public notice on July 14, 2000. No petitions to deny or other objections or comments were filed in response to the public notice. III. DISCUSSION A. Public Interest Considerations 2. Under Section 310(d) of the Communications Act, we must find that a proposed transaction serves the public interest, convenience, and necessity before we can approve the transfer of control of authorizations or licenses. To make this finding, we must weigh any potential public interest harms against any potential public interest benefits, considering competitive effects and other public interest factors. In conducting our analysis of potential public interest harms and public interest benefits, we first take note of the fact that no party has opposed this transaction. 3. To evaluate the competitive effects of the proposed transaction, the Commission first identifies the relevant product and geographic markets. For satellite service providers, the Commission has determined that the relevant product markets include domestic and international telecommunications markets. In such cases, we consider whether the proposed transaction will lessen or enhance competition in the provision of communications services in, to or from the United States. 4. According to the parties, upon consummation of the proposed transaction, Craig O. McCaw and his affiliated companies will exercise de jure and de facto control of Teledesic and ICO, under ITGL's corporate umbrella. Currently, neither Teledesic nor ICO provide telecommunications services within the United States or internationally, as neither company has any operating facilities or services at this time. Accordingly, this transaction will not eliminate an existing competitor in any telecommunications service market. Mr. McCaw does have substantial interests in at least two operational Commission licensees: a commercial mobile radio service ("CMRS") operator, Nextel Communications, Inc. ("Nextel"), and a competitive local exchange carrier, XO Communications, Inc. ("XO"). We note that Teledesic plans to provide worldwide, broadband access to the Internet, computer networking, interactive multimedia and high-quality voice, and ICO plans to provide global Internet protocol services, including data, standard voice and fax services. Both Nextel and XO provide, or plan to provide, similar services terrestrially to customers seeking individualized market coverage. However, it appears unlikely within the near-term future that either of these firms is capable of offering the ubiquitous worldwide services proposed by Teledesic and ICO to customers demanding extended global coverage, such as maritime users, the transportation, oil and gas and construction industries, and governmental agencies. Thus, this merger is not likely to increase significantly Mr. McCaw's ability to exercise market power in the provision of domestic telecommunications services, nor will it adversely affect competition in any international telecommunications market. 5. In evaluating the public interest benefits of this transaction, we review the parties' claims of public interest benefits based on a consolidation of resources and increased operational efficiencies. Particularly, we note Teledesic's assertion that the proposed transaction will strengthen its financial position, enabling the resulting entity to attract financing more effectively, and thus, expedite the construction, launch, and operation of its global satellite constellation, originally licensed in 1997. According to ICO, the ITGL financing package increases the likelihood that ICO will complete build-out of its system and launch service rapidly, bringing wider choice of MSS services and service providers to U.S. consumers. Given our finding that the proposed transaction is not likely to cause competitive harm in either domestic or international telecommunications services, we find that there should be significant competitive and other public interest benefits in authorizing this transaction, including moving idle assets into productive use. Therefore, on balance, we find that the proposed transaction is in the public interest under Section 310(d) of the Communications Act. F. Cut-Off Rule 7. ICO has an LOI pending in the 2 GHz MSS space station processing round. This processing round was established pursuant to public notices in which the Commission established filing deadlines for applications and LOIs. Applications or LOIs filed after a cut-off date are not entitled to comparative consideration with applications or LOIs filed on or before the cut-off date. 8. Section 25.116(c) of the Commission's rules provides generally that if a major amendment to a processing round application is submitted after a cut-off date, the application will be considered to be newly filed, and will lose its status in the processing group. Section 25.116(b)(3) defines a major amendment as, inter alia, one that "specifies a substantial change in beneficial ownership or control" of the underlying entity. Section 25.116(c)(2) allows for an exemption to the cut-off rule, however, where the major amendment reflects only a change in ownership or control found by the Commission to be in the public interest and for which a requested exemption from the cut-off date is granted. ICO requests such an exemption, acknowledging that the merger of Teledesic into ITGL disclosed in the ICO LOI Amendment presents a significant change in the beneficial ownership and control of ICO. In previous decisions in which the International Bureau granted an exemption to the cut-off rules, the Bureau considered two factors: (1) whether the proposed transaction had a legitimate business purpose; and (2) whether the change in ownership otherwise served the public interest. 9. With respect to the first factor, the Commission's overriding concern is whether the applicant or LOI filer has attempted to profit solely from the sale of an application. Unless there is evidence of this, we see no reason to prevent applicants or LOI filers from procuring partners to help finance the enormous cost of these systems. Because the transactions described in the ICO LOI Amendment involve a reorganization and infusion of capital necessary for ICO to emerge from bankruptcy, there are no substantial questions concerning profits deriving solely from the sale of an application. ICO has articulated a clearly defined and legitimate business purpose for its transfers of control to New ICO and ultimately, post-merger ITGL: in order to emerge from bankruptcy, launch its satellites, and deploy its service, it was essential that ICO obtain the new financing provided by the group of investors led by Mr. McCaw. We find that the transfers of control disclosed in the ICO LOI Amendment serve a legitimate business purpose, and are not primarily for acquiring pending applications. 10. With respect to the second factor, for the reasons discussed in Section III.A. above, we find that the public interest would be served by approving the change in ownership. Consequently, we will exempt ICO's pending LOI from the Section 25.116(c) cut-off rule, and will continue to consider ICO's LOI concurrently with the other applications and LOIs in the 2 GHz MSS processing group. Although ICO argues that this rule is not applicable to LOI filers, in light of our conclusion that continued consideration of ICO's LOI would serve the public interest, we need not address this contention. IV. CONCLUSION 11. In view of the foregoing, we find that approval of the proposed transaction will serve the public interest, convenience and necessity by increasing competition in the satellite services market to the benefit of U.S. consumers. For this reason, and the reasons described in this Order, we grant ITGL's application for consent to the transfer of Teledesic LLC's authorization to construct, launch, and operate an NGSO FSS system in the Ka-band frequencies from Teledesic to ITGL. We also grant ICO's related request for exemption of Section 25.116(c) of the Commission's rules, which will allow ICO to prosecute its pending LOI in the 2 GHz MSS processing round, notwithstanding the significant change in the beneficial ownership and control of ICO resulting from merger of Teledesic into ITGL. V. ORDERING CLAUSES 12. Accordingly, IT IS ORDERED that the FCC Form 312 Application for Transfer of Control of Space Station License of Teledesic LLC to ICO-Teledesic Global Limited, File No. SAT-T/C-20000531-00097, IS GRANTED. 13. IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that the Petition for Declaratory Ruling filed by ICO Services Limited, File No. SAT-PDR-20000612-00106, IS DENIED to the extent indicated herein. 14. IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that, pursuant to Section 25.116(c)(2) of the Commission's rules, 47 C.F.R.  25.116(c)(2), the request of ICO Services Limited for an exemption from the space station processing round cut-off rule IS GRANTED, and that the consummation of the transactions disclosed in the ICO LOI Amendment, File No. SAT-AMD-20000612- 00107, will not disqualify ICO's Letter of Intent, File Nos. 188-SAT-LOI-97, SAT-LOI- 19970926-00163, SAT-AMD-20000612-00107, SAT-AMD-20001103-00155, from Commission consideration in the currently-pending 2 GHz MSS processing group. 15. IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that the transaction approved herein shall be completed within 60 days from the date of this Order. Within 30 days of consummation, ICO- Teledesic Global Limited shall notify the Commission in writing of the date of consummation and the file numbers of the applications involved in the transaction. 47 C.F.R.  25.119(f). 16. This Order is issued pursuant to Section 0.261 of the Commission's rules on delegated authority, 47 C.F.R.  0.261, and is effective upon release. FEDERAL COMMUNICATIONS COMMISSION Donald Abelson Chief, International Bureau