Report No. MM95-5 MASS MEDIA ACTION January 13, 1994 HOUSTON ACADEMY GRANTED CP AND LICENSE FOR ITFS CHANNELS A1-A4 AT DOTHAN, AL, WITH CONDITIONS The Commission has granted the application of Houston Academy for a construction permit and license in the Instructional Television Fixed Service (ITFS) on Channels A1-A4, at Dothan, AL; and denied the competing applications of Barbour County Board of Education and Geneva County Board of Education for ITFS channels at Ariton and Elba, AL, respectively. In cases of mutually exclusive applications, where applicants are competing for the same or adjacent channels in the same geographic area, each application is reviewed pursuant to the Commission's comparative process. This procedure awards a maximum of 12 merit points based on five criteria deemed most relevant to predicting the applicant best qualified to provide the service for which the ITFS spectrum was allocated. Barbour, Geneva and Houston were awarded a total of 10 points: four points for being local, three points for being accredited, two points for observing the four-channel limitation, and one point for proposing at least 21 hours of formal educational programming per channel per week. Because the applicants were tied, the Commission used its tie-breaker mechanism to determine the winning applicant. When the comparative procedure results in a tie among two or more applicants, the parties are given 30 days from notification to negotiate an agreement regarding the use of channels. Because the applicants failed to reach an agreement regarding the use of the channels, the Commission used the enrollment figures submitted by each applicant. In this case, the Commission credited Barbour with 1,920 students and Geneva with 2,840 students. Houston submitted timely and properly executed documentation showing that a total of 21,832 students would be served at its receive sites. Because the numbers of students credited to Barbour and Geneva were less than 80 percent of the number of students credited to Houston, the Commission authorized Houston to operate facilities on Channels A1-A4, and denied the applications of Barbour and Geneva. (over) -2- Houston proposed leasing its excess capacity for non ITFS use and submitted a copy of its lease with Wiregrass Cable Television. However, the lease failed to conform with FCC requirements. The Commission stated that the non-conformity of the lease agreement did not reflect adversely on Houston's basic or comparative qualifications or preclude the grant of an authorization. Thus, the Commission conditioned Houston's authorization upon conformity of the lease agreement with Commission requirements. Action by the Commission January 3, 1995, by Memorandum Opinion and Order (FCC 95-6). Chairman Hundt, Commissioners Quello, Barrett, Ness, and Chong. -FCC- News Media contact: Patricia A. Chew at (202) 418-0500. Mass Media Bureau contact: Marlene Dortch at (202) 418-1630.