Report No. DC-2593 ACTION IN DOCKET CASE April 20, 1994 COMMENTS SOUGHT ON FURTHER REGULATORY FORBEARANCE FOR SMALL CMRS PROVIDERS (GEN DOCKET 94-33) The Commission has asked for comments on whether and how to forbear further from applying certain common carrier regulations to specific types of commercial mobile radio service (CMRS) providers. In the Second Report and Order in GEN Docket 93-252, the Commission classified all mobile radio services as either commercial mobile radio service (CMRS) or private mobile radio service (PMRS) and determined, pursuant to the Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act of 1993 (Budget Act), to forbear from applying the most burdensome sections of Title II of the Communications Act to any service classified as CMRS. At that time, the Commission determined that it would not forbear regulation under the remaining sections of Title II with respect to CMRS providers. The Commission determined that this decision would not place an undue burden on any CMRS provider or class of providers. At that time, however, the Commission also announced that it would conduct a further rulemaking that would gather a more extensive record to ensure that the potential effect of the remaining sections of Title II on particular types of CMRS providers within each class of service was nevertheless in the public interest. Forbearance is a decision by the Commission not to apply certain regulatory obligations in particular cases. The Budget Act allows the Commission to decide to forbear from application of certain sections of Title II in cases where (1) enforcement is not necessary to ensure just, reasonable and nondiscriminatory rates, (2) enforcement of the provision is not necessary to protect consumers, and (3) forbearance is consistent with the public interest. Pursuant to the statute, the Commission may not forbear from those sections of Title II requiring just and reasonable rates and nondiscriminatory practices and those associated with the complaint remedy. (over) - 2 - The Commission's initial forbearance substantially reduced the potential burden of complying with new CMRS regulation. In today's action, the Commission begins a proceeding to ensure that this decision has its intended effect. The Commission seeks comment on how the three-part statutory test for forbearance applies to those provisions of Title II, many of which are consumer-oriented, that continue to apply to CMRS. In connection with the third prong of the statutory test,-- that forbearance from application of a provision is in the public interest,-- the Commission tentatively identified two factors that would guide its public interest determination: The first is whether there are differential costs of complying with the remaining common carrier provisions that would make further forbearance appropriate for particular types of providers, such as, for example small entities. The second is whether the public interest benefits from application of particular provisions are less for certain types of providers. In determining the particular types of CMRS providers that may be appropriate for further forbearance, the Commission focussed on small business entities because, if the costs of compliance with the remaining provisions of Title II are fixed, the additional regulation could prove disproportionately burdensome to small business. It also asked whether further forbearance could increase market participation by small businesses, thereby increasing the over-all level of competition in the CMRS market. Recognizing the public interest in maintaining opportunities for small businesses and the role that further forbearance might play in reducing the cost of doing business for them, the Commission focused on the size of the provider as the basis for examining when it might be appropriate to subject certain classes of CMRS providers to further forbearance. It asked for comments on how to measure the size of CMRS providers, advancing several options. These options include examining the net worth, average annual revenues, or average number of subscribers for particular providers; considering various operational characteristics, such as number of authorized channels, as indications of size for CMRS providers licensed under Part 90 of the rules; or handling further forbearance on a case-by-case basis, with particular CMRS providers petitioning for further forbearance based on a showing that they have satisfied the statutory test for forbearance. Action by the Commission April 20, 1994, by Notice of Proposed Rulemaking (FCC 94-101). Chairman Hundt, Commissioners Quello and Barrett. - FCC - News Media contact: Rosemary Kimball at (202) 632-5050. Private Radio Bureau contacts: Gina Harrison at (202) 632-7125 and Susan McNeil at (202) 634-2443. Common Carrier Bureau contact: Peter Batacan at (202) 632- 6917.