Report No. DC-2634 ACTION IN DOCKET CASE August 2, 1994 FCC PROPOSES TO ELIMINATE RULES BANNING WIRELINES FROM SMR AND COMMERCIAL 220 MHz SERVICES AND PROHIBITING COMMON CARRIERS FROM ENGAGING IN RADIO DISPATCH SERVICE (GN DOCKET NO. 94-90) The FCC today proposed to eliminate the rules that now prohibit wireline telephone carriers from holding licenses in the Specialized Mobile Radio (SMR) service and the commercial 220-222 MHz land mobile band. Additionally, the Commission sought comment on a proposal to eliminate its current prohibition on common carriers providing radio dispatch service. The Commission said that "the proposed rule changes represent a significant step toward eliminating potentially outmoded regulation, promoting competition in the mobile services marketplace and enhancing consumer choice." The Commission currently prohibits wireline telephone companies who provide local exchange service from holding SMR or commercial licenses in the 220 MHz band. The wireline ban on SMR licenses was adopted when the service was first created in 1974, based on the Commission's view that wireline entry could otherwise restrain competition in the fledgling SMR industry. When 220-222 MHz service was established in 1991,the Commission adopted an identical restriction on wireline eligibility for commercial licenses in that service. The Commission indicated that the rationale for excluding wirelines from SMR licensing also served as the basis for the commercial 220 MHz limitation. In proposing to repeal the wireline exclusion, the Commission cited dramatic changes in the mobile services marketplace since the first ban on SMR licensing was adopted in 1974, as well as changes to the Communications Act, which may cause the restrictions to be outmoded. In particular, in light of ongoing efforts to restructure its regulatory scheme for mobile services, and to establish PCS and other new forms of competition, the Commission indicated there is a need to examine whether the existing wireline restrictions serve a useful purpose in today's marketplace. (over) -2- The Commission has acknowledged the evolving role of wirelines in the mobile services arena in its recent PCS proceedings. In those proceedings, the Commission determined that allowing wireline carriers to participate in broadband and narrowband PCS would produce significant economies of scope between wireline and PCS networks, which, in turn, would promote rapid development of PCS and yield a broader array of PCS services at lower costs to consumers. In its proposal today, the Commission observed that its conclusions with respect to wireline entry into PCS are also potentially applicable to SMR and 220 MHz commercial service. In addition, the Commission questioned whether the wireline restrictions are still necessary to protect against competitive harm. The Commission observed that other regulatory safeguards exist and can be enforced to protect against wirelines with SMR or commercial 220 MHz affiliates from engaging in discriminatory interconnection practices, or cross-subsidizing services in order to undercut competition. In light of the above factors, the Commission proposed to eliminate its wireline eligibility restrictions in both the SMR and 220 MHz services, but seeks comment on whether there are any grounds for retaining the rules for one or both services. With respect to the common carrier dispatch prohibition, Congress in the 1993 Budget Act recently gave the Commission the discretion to terminate this statutory restriction in whole or in part. The Commission believes it should reevaluate the prohibition in light of current competitive conditions in the mobile services marketplace. The Commission noted that in other proceedings parties have already indicated that repeal of the dispatch ban could potentially enhance competition in the dispatch market and provide consumers with expanded choice at lower cost. The Commission therefore seeks comment on the state of competition in the dispatch market in order to determine whether an outright repeal or sunset of the ban is justified. Action by the Commission August 2, 1994, by Notice of Proposed Rulemaking (FCC 94-202). Chairman Hundt, Commissioners Quello, Barrett, Ness, and Chong. -FCC- News Media contacts: Patricia A. Chew and Susan Sallet at (202) 418-0500. Private Radio Bureau contacts: Kathleen O'Brien Ham and Sue McNeil at(202)634-2443.