Report No. DC-2647 ACTION IN DOCKET CASE August 25, 1994 COMMISSION AMENDS RULES CONCERNING THE LICENSING OF RESPONSE CHANNELS, ATTRIBUTION, AND PUERTO RICO SERVICE AREA IN THE NARROWBAND PCS SERVICE (GEN DOCKET NO. 90-314 AND ET DOCKET NO. 92-100) The FCC has amended its rules concerning the licensing of response channels in the narrowband personal communications service (PCS). The Commission also modified its attribution rule with regard to narrowband PCS licenses in future application proceedings and revised its local service area definition to provide two service areas in Puerto Rico. The Commission believes these changes will improve the fairness of the licensing process for narrowband PCS and provide for more effective use of the narrowband PCS spectrum. Previously, in the First Report and Order (R&O), the Commission allocated three megahertz of spectrum at 900 MHz for the narrowband PCS service, made two of the three megahertz available for immediate licensing, and adopted rules to govern narrowband PCS operation. The Commission designated eight 12.5 kHz response channels for use by existing common carrier (Part 22) and private (Part 90) paging licensees. (Response channels provide existing paging systems with two-way capability, including acknowledgement of a page and advanced messaging capability.) In the Memorandum Opinion and Order (MO&O), the Commission designated four of the eight response channels for Major Trading Area (MTA) licensing and four for Basic Trading Area (BTA) licensing. The Commission also restricted eligibility for these channels to paging licensees authorized under Part 22 or Part 90 as of the June 24, 1993, adoption date of the R&O. The Commission stated that to be eligible for a response channel license, the existing paging licensee must operate at least one base station in the MTA or BTA for which it requests a license. Finally, the Commission limited each licensee to two paging response channels per geographic area. (over) - 2 - In response to a petition for further reconsideration filed by the National Association of Business and Educational Radio, Inc., the Commission: 1) based eligibility on an existing base station's service area; 2) allowed paging licensees authorized as of the auction application deadline for response channels to compete in the auction; and 3) limited licensees to two response channels per geographic area for two years after licensing. Additionally, on its own motion, the Commission clarified its attribution rule with regard to indirect ownership of narrowband PCS licenses to include a "multiplier" to determine effective ownership interest in future application proceedings; and divided Puerto Rico into two BTAs, instead of a single BTA. With respect to the attribution rule, the Commission concluded that a multiplier, which takes account of ownership interests held by intervening parties, would better facilitate a competitive narrowband PCS market than the prior rule, which took account only of ownership interests in an entity holding a narrowband PCS license. Under the multiplier rule, ownership interests are attributable if, when multiplied together, they equal or exceed five percent. For example, if Party A has a non- controlling ownership interest of 40 percent in Company B, which in turn has a non-controlling ownership interest of 40 percent in Company C, the narrowband PCS licensee, then Party A's effective ownership interest in Company C is 16 percent, and is attributable. With regard to Puerto Rico, the Commission decided that it is desirable to modify the local service area in the same manner as was done in broadband PCS. The Commission concluded that the patterns of local trade caused by the mountainous terrain of Puerto Rico and the relatively large population of the island support dividing it into two BTAs. Action by the Commission August 16, 1994, by Second Memorandum Opinion and Order (FCC 94-218). Chairman Hundt, Commissioners Quello, Barrett, Ness, and Chong. -FCC- News Media contact: Patricia A. Chew at (202) 418-0500; Office of Engineering and Technology contact: Tom Mooring at (202) 653-8114.