Commissioner Pai's Statment on Media Bureau's New Guidance
Federal Communications Commission
News Media Information: (202) 418-0500445 12th Street, S.W.
Washington, D. C. 20554
TTY: (888) 835-5322
This is an unofficial announcement of Commission action. Release of the full text of a Commission order constitutes official action.
See MCI v. FCC
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
March 12, 2014
Matthew Berry (202) 418-2005
STATEMENT OF FCC COMMISSIONER AJIT PAI
ON THE MEDIA BUREAU’S NEW GUIDANCE
ON SHARING ARRANGEMENTS AND CONTINGENT INTERESTSToday, the Media Bureau warns broadcasters that it “will closely scrutinize” any transaction that
involves both a sharing agreement and a contingent financial interest.1 When I objected, I was told that
the Public Notice merely clarified existing Commission policy. It does not.
How so? The Public Notice does not cite any Commission (or even Bureau) precedent involving
both a sharing agreement and a contingent financial interest. And for good reason. In response to a
request from my office, the Bureau was unable to cite any order where the Commission or the Bureau
denied a license transfer because the transaction involved both a sharing agreement and a contingent
financial interest. To the contrary, the Bureau has issued numerous orders approving such transfers.
Indeed, just three months ago, the Bureau explained: “The Commission has approved applications for
consent to television station transactions involving a combination of joint sales agreements, other types of
shared services agreements, options, and similar contingent interests and guarantees of third-party debt
financing, and has found these cooperative arrangements not to rise to the level of an attributable
interest.”2 It is impossible to square what was said then with what is being said now.
1 Processing of Broadcast Television Applications Proposing Sharing Arrangements and Contingent Interests,
Public Notice, DA 14-330, at 2 (Med. Bur. Mar. 12, 2014).
2 Applications for Consent to Transfer of Control from Shareholders of Belo Corp. to Gannett Co., Inc.,
Applications For Consent to Assignment of Licenses from Subsidiaries of Belo Corp. to Subsidiaries of Sander
Media, LLC and Tucker Operating Co., LLC, MB Docket No. 13-189, File Nos. BTCCDT - 20130619AAY et seq.,
Memorandum Opinion and Order, 28 FCC Rcd 16867, 16878, para. 27 (Med. Bur. Dec. 20, 2013); see also, e.g.,
Applications of Local TV Holdings, LLC, Transferor & Tribune Broad. Co. II, LLC, Transferee & Dreamcatcher
Broad., LLC, Transferee For Consent to Transfer of Control of Certain Licensee Subsidiaries of Local TV Holdings,
LLC, MB Docket No. 13-190, File Nos. BTCCDT-20130715AER et al., File Nos. BTCCDT-20130715AGP et al.,
Memorandum Opinion and Order, 28 FCC Rcd 16850, 16857, para. 17 (Med. Bur. 2013) (noting, where a shared
service agreement (SSA), lease, and option were at issue, that the agreements were “fully compliant with our
precedent and [did] not implicate our attribution rules”); J. Stewart Bryan III & Media Gen. Commc’ns Holdings,
LLC (Transferor), Shareholders of New Young Broadcasting Holding Company, Inc., and Its Subsidiaries
(Transferor) and Post-Merger Shareholders of Media General, Inc. (Transferee) For Consent to Transfer Control of
Licenses, MB Docket No. 13-191, File No. BTCCDT-20130703ABQ et al., Memorandum Opinion and Order, 28
FCC Rcd 15509 (Med. Bur. 2013) (approving transfer where SSA, joint sales agreement (JSA), and loan guarantee
were at issue); Saga Broad., LLC c/o Gary S. Smithwick, Esq. H3 Commc’ns, LLC c/o David Tillotson, Esq., File
No. BALCDT - 20120501ACQ, Facility ID No. 25236, Letter, 28 FCC Rcd 399 (Med. Bur. 2013) (approving
transfer where SSA and loan guarantee were at issue); Sagamorehill of Corpus Christi Licenses, LLC c/o Todd
Stansbury, Esq. Eagle Creek Broad. of Corpus Christi, LLC c/o Dennis Corbett, Esq. Channel 3 of Corpus Christi,
So make no mistake about it: Today’s Public Notice announces a new policy. This abuse of
delegated authority is all the more unfortunate because it is entirely unnecessary. At our March 31
meeting, the Commission will vote on an item addressing sharing agreements. If the majority of the
Commission wanted to turn the screws still further on broadcasters, the substance of today’s Public
Notice easily could have been included in that item. Instead, our policy has been changed without a
Commission vote. That’s not the way we should do business.
Inc. c/o Robert B. Jacobi, Esq., File No. BALCT-20080730AKQ, Letter, 25 FCC Rcd 2809 (Med. Bur. 2010)
(approving transfer where SSA, JSA, option, studio lease, and loan guarantee were at issue); Piedmont Television of
Springfield License LLC c/o Joseph Di Scipio, Esq., Perkin Media, LLC c/o Dawn M. Sciarrino, Esq., EBC
Harrison, Inc. c/o Peter Tannenwald, Esq., Koplar Communications International, Inc. c/o Charles R. Naftalin,
Letter, 22 FCC Rcd 13910 (Med. Bur. 2007) (approving transfer where SSA, JSA, option, studio lease, loan
guarantee, and sale of non-license assets were at issue); Chelsey Broad. Co. of Youngstown, LLC c/o William Fitz,
Esq. Parkin Broad. of Youngstown License, LLC c/o Howard M. Liberman, Esq. Elizabeth A. Hammond, Esq. Paula
M. Olson, File No. BALCT-20070205ACH, Letter, 22 FCC Rcd 13905 (Med. Bur. 2007) (approving transfer where
SSA, option, and loan guarantee were at issue); Malara Broad. Grp. of Duluth Licensee LLC c/o Stuart A
Shorenstein, Esq., NVG-Duluth II, LLC c/o Elizabeth Hammond, Esq., KQDS Acquisition Corp & WDIO-TV, LLC
c/o Marvin Rosenberg, Esq., File No. BALCT-20040504ABU, Letter, 19 FCC Rcd 24070 (Med. Bur. 2004)
(approving transfer where SSA, JSA, option, lease, and loan guarantee were at issue).
Note: We are currently transitioning our documents into web compatible formats for easier reading. We have done our best to supply this content to you in a presentable form, but there may be some formatting issues while we improve the technology. The original version of the document is available as a PDF, Word Document, or as plain text.